Main Content

Property Details

Property
Property

01 1 Lily Pond Ln East Hampton, NY 11937

02 1 Lily Pond Ln East Hampton, NY 11937

The Gateway To Lily Pond | East Hampton's Original Summer Colony

A once-in-generations opportunity to own an East Hampton icon. The Frederick G. Potter House is a grand shingle-style cottage commanding the approach to Main Beach and the entrance to Lily Pond Lane, built in 1905 by renowned architect Joseph Greenleaf Thorp. Situated on a sprawling 1.5-acre estate, the three-story home offers panoramic views from Hook Pond to the Atlantic Ocean. Gentle sounds of surf and a refreshing breeze signal its close proximity to legendary Main Beach up the block and Hook Pond across the street. The main level features an array of spacious rooms, each with unique charm: a welcoming foyer and sun room, a private study, two comfortable living areas, a formal dining room, a well-appointed kitchen, and an intimate second dining area. Step outside the kitchen onto a large brick patio, perfect for al fresco dining with under open skies surrounded by beautiful gardens and ancient perimeter trees. The expansive grounds offer rolling lawns and an elevated pool area, ideal for relaxation and enjoyment on sunny days. Adjacent to the pool, a charming pool house offers convenience and a respite from the sun's rays. Venture upstairs to find seven bedrooms and six bathrooms on the second floor, including a primary suite with dual full bathrooms. Ascend to the third floor, offering seven more bedrooms and two bathrooms. Large gracious porches around the first and second floors provide comfortable lounging areas with commanding ocean views. The Frederick G. Potter House is more than a home; it's a cherished testament to East Hampton's enduring heritage. Embrace the past and secure your future with this exceptional estate. Contact us today for an exclusive viewing.

Active Status
$21,900,000 Price
13 Beds
8+ Baths
1.5 Acres
7,500 SqFt.
Listing by Compass (63 Main Street, East Hampton NY 11937)
Last Verified: Apr 3, 2025

03 Property Highlights

Pool Gunite Pool Waterfront Oceanview Parking Garage, 2 Spaces Location South of the Highway

04 Property Details

Home Details
Property Type Single-family Home
Property Style Cottage
New Construction No
Year Built 1905
Square Footage 7,500
Price Per Square Foot $2,920/sqft
Basement Type Partial
Stories 3
Floors Hardwood
Bedrooms 13
Full Bathrooms 8
Half Bathrooms 2
Bathrooms on First Floor Yes
Bonus room, Family room/den, Great room, In-law suite/private guest quarters, Laundry room, Loft, Study
Water Source Towm
Heat Type Oil hot water
Central Air Conditioning No
Financial Details
Price $21,900,000
Taxes $22,661/yr
Outdoor Details
Pool Yes
Pool Material Gunite
Garage Yes
Space in Garage 2
Tennis No
Toom for a Tennis Court No
Water Frontage/View Oceanview
Outdoor Shower(s) Yes
Beach Rights Yes
Lot Size 1.5 Acres
Near Jitney Sunrise Bus Line Yes
Near Train Station Yes
South Highway Yes
Photo
Location
Nearby Beaches
0 Miles East Hampton Main Beach
1 Mile Wiborg Beach
1 Mile Georgica Beach
Nearby Transportation
0 Miles PedalShare: Main Beach
1 Mile East Hamptop - Hamptons Luxury Liner
1 Mile East Hampton - Hampton Jitney
Price History
Date Events Price
09/08/24 Price Change $21,900,000
09/08/24 Listed For Sale $25,000,000
09/08/24 Price Change $25,000,000
09/08/24 Listed For Sale $25,000,000
About The Area
The Hamptions’ Most Exclusive Club

East Hampton is a historic community that has worked hard to preserve its past, while becoming one of the most sought-after markets in the country. It’s a destination where the well-heeled come to vacation, shop, dine, and take advantage of some of the best sandy beaches in the U.S.

Listing Info
Agent(s)
Ed Petrie
Licensed Associate Broker
Compass - East Hampton
516.885.9365
James Petrie
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Compass - East Hampton
631.830.2084
Charles Forsman
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Compass - East Hampton
917.208.2480

07 Any Questions? Get in Touch
With Us

    Skip to content